Skip to main content

Why Is History a Required Subject?

My daughter Mara has been asking for Susan Wise Bauer's The Story of the World: History for the Classical Child, Volume 3: Early Modern Times
ever since she finished volume 2. So Santa brought her volume 3 and The Story of the World: History for the Classical Child, Volume 4: The Modern Age: From Victoria's Empire to the End of the USSR
for Christmas. She's devouring them, and thought that she got better presents than her sisters who got stereos and MP3 players. At last check, she was reading about the great fire of London, and commenting the need for building codes. (That discussion is food for another post...)

I am also very much into history. I have two complete bookcases filled with history and biography, including a complete set of Will Durrants The Story of Civilization and Britanica's 18 Volume The Annals of America and 2 volume Great Issues in American Life (Volumes 1 - 18 and two volume Conspectus)

In that context, last night Amy and I were listening to Showtunes Saturday Night. Laura played "Wonderful" from the musical Wicked near the end of the show. There's a section of the lyric that caught my attention:


WIZARD(spoken) See - I never had a family of my own. So, I guess I just - wanted
to give the citizens of Oz everything.

ELPHABA(spoken) So you lied to them.

WIZARD(spoken) Elphaba, where I'm from, we believe all sorts of things that aren't true. We call it - "history."
(sung) A man's called a traitor -
or liberator
A rich man's a thief -
or philanthropist
Is one a crusader -
or ruthless invader?
It's all in which label
Is able to persist
There are
precious few at ease
With moral ambiguities
So we act as though they don't
exist

That got me thinking about what is taught as "History" in our schools and the
purpose it serves. When we teach that someone like Thomas Jefferson was a great political leader and philosopher, put him on a pedestal and revere him as a near god, are were really teaching the lessons of History to prevent making the same mistakes our forebears made, or are we indoctrinating our children to believe in a set of previously decided political ideals? And I have to ask if the political ideals that are being taught are the same ideals that Jefferson adhered to.

Don't we need to teach our children about the foibles of men like Jefferson, Washington, Lincoln and so on? I use Jefferson as an example because there were so many things he did that, when viewed with a critical eye, cause me to scratch my head. The Embargo act that nearly bankrupted the fledgling American Economy; his misreading of the French Revolution that nearly got us back into war with England; the Louisiana Purchase that wrecked the doctrine of strict interpretation of the Constitution (an ideal that Jefferson held close until it became expedient to toss it away). From a personal standpoint, Jefferson couldn't manage his money and died bankrupt, owing more than $200,000 (in 1826 dollars) after his estate was liquidated; I shudder to think what he would have done with a credit card! And then there's the question of his progeny with Sally Hemmings.

But more importantly, shouldn't our history curriculum teach our children to critically examine the events of history to find the lessons that can be applied to the present? If we examine the Embargo and Jefferson's strict stance on neutrality, we can see where the need to further commerce trumps the need to stay neutral in "foreign entanglements." Understanding how he misread the French revolution should inform us of the arrogance of trying to export American political ideals; and the Louisiana Purchase should bring the point home that no matter how well crafted a Constitution may be, government will always find a way to circumvent its guarantees and promises.

Don't mistake my purpose here. I think the founding fathers were great men, and I think the great experiment of the American republic was a wonderful development in the history of the world. And I love my country... But the learning of history needs to be more than an indoctrination into the "politically-correct" idealism of the current ruling elite, or it serves no purpose other than to create a class of drones that work at the bidding of the elite classes. I think a lot of religious history falls into this practice as well (and it doesn't matter which religion we're talking about.) I wonder if Hitler would have been such a menace if Germany hadn't taught dogmatic history in the first part of the 20th Century.

Food for thought....

Comments

Unknown said…
It is good to see you posting again :) By the way I noticed you are linked to my old blog still. My new blog is thoughtsofliz.blogspot.com

I am looking forward to even more posts from you!
Tad Wimmer said…
Back in August, Amy and I swapped places so that I could dedicate more time to OHPAA and the Empress... One of those best laid plans of mice and men things, I ended up with less time that I had when I was working full time, and almost no time available to work at the Empress.

Now that neither of us is working, I have time to blog again. Go figure.

Popular posts from this blog

Agregate Demand and the US Savings Rate

In my last post, I touched on the differences between the economic theories of John Maynard Keynes and Ludwig von Mises. Immediately aftward, I was directed to this story in the New York Times. It seems that americans are saving more instead of spending the their money on consumer goods. Up until this downturn, about 70% of the US Economy was consumer spending, and in 2005, the US Savings rate was negative 2.7%. The "stimulus" is supposed to stimulate spending to get money moving again. But it isn't happening as planned. Folks are saving for down payments because they don't expect to get zero down home mortgages; they're saving to replenish their decimated retirement and college funds. The austrians believe that the best way to "fix" the economy is to allow the "malinvestment" created by the false signals in the economy (from the open market ops and deficit spending) to be liquidated and the resources repurposed into better investments. It...

Conventional Wisdom Meets Reality:
There Ought Not to be a Law

The "before" picture of an intersection near Bristol, England: Maximum traffic of 1700 cars per hour and about 300 pedestrians. Commute time for some people using the intersection over 20 minutes in rush hour traffic. The "after" picture: Traffic flow increased to 2000 cars per hour, and still handles the 300 pedestrians. Commute time reduced to just 5 minutes. In the eight months since the change, there have only been two minor incidents, and not a single person (motorist or pedestrian) has been injured in an accident. How did they do it? What new technology did they use to effect this miraculous change? They took out the traffic conrol signals! Yes, you read that right, the traffic lights were removed. By removing all of the red, yellow and green lights, the motorists became more courteous, more cautious, and more sharing of the road way. In complete defiance of the conventional wisdom. This experiment raises a lot of very interesting questions. First, do our pre...

Haiti Adoption Story

Most of us have seen or read stories of adoptions of Haitian children following the earthquake last month. Some of the stories have had a positive slant (the charity has saved children...) other's have had a negative slant (the "missionaries" who kidnapped and tried to smuggle 33 children across the border into the Dominican Republic). At a family gathering yesterday, my wife heard a story about a couple that was "finally" able to adopt a child they've been trying to adopt for about 4 years. As the story was related to me, this couple had originally been matched with this child about 4 years ago, but the adoption was cancelled when the parents of the child took her back and parented her themselves. After about three years of caring for the child, the natural parents returned her to the orphanage because both of them had been diagnosed with tuberculosis; a death sentence in Haiti. (Mortality for untreated TB is about 67%.) The adoption was finalized just befo...